Our Story
Newton's Independent Insurance Agency Since 1946
For over 75 years, Catawba First Insurance Associates has been the agency that families and businesses in Catawba County trust when it matters most.
Our Mission
Protecting What Matters Most to You
Catawba First Insurance Associates was founded on a single belief: that every person deserves honest, expert guidance when it comes to protecting their home, family, and livelihood.
As an independent agency, we are not beholden to any single insurance company. We work for our clients — shopping our network of 12+ top-rated carriers to find the coverage that genuinely fits your situation, not the policy that pays us the highest commission.
Over the decades, we have built a reputation for being the agency that picks up the phone, explains coverage in plain English, and stands beside our clients during claims. That's not a marketing promise — it's how we have operated since 1946.
Get a Free Quote
What Guides Us
Our Core Values
Client-First Always
Every decision we make starts with one question: what is best for the client? Not the carrier, not our commission.
Honest Guidance
We explain your options in plain English, including the coverage you might not need, so you can make confident decisions.
Community Rooted
We live in Newton. We shop at the same stores, attend the same schools, and care about this community the way you do.
Lasting Protection
We build policies designed to last — reviewing your coverage annually as your life evolves.
The People Behind the Policy
Meet Our Team
Kevin Black
Agency Principal & Licensed Agent
Kevin has led Catawba First Insurance Associates for over 15 years. His straightforward approach and deep carrier relationships consistently deliver better rates and coverage for clients.
Susan Hartley
Senior Personal Lines Agent
Susan specializes in home, auto, and life insurance. Her patient, educational approach has made her one of the most trusted agents in Catawba County.
Sherry Caldwell
Commercial Lines Specialist
Sherry brings 20+ years of commercial insurance expertise to every business client. From small retailers to contractors, she builds coverage that actually protects.
Harley Munroe
Commercial Auto & Fleet Specialist
Harley handles our commercial auto and fleet accounts with precision. His clients appreciate his speed, attention to detail, and ability to simplify complex multi-vehicle programs.
Ready to Experience the Catawba First Difference?
Get a free, no-obligation quote today and see why thousands of families trust us with their most important coverage.